> For clean Markdown of any page, append .md to the page URL.
> For a complete documentation index, see https://docs.beatapi.io/llms.txt.
> For AI client integration (Claude Code, Cursor, etc.), connect to the MCP server at https://docs.beatapi.io/_mcp/server.

# How do I continue from a shared Zhihu answer to other viewpoints and comments?

> Keep question and answer IDs separately, select same-question answers or comments, and distinguish articles and user identifiers.

**A Zhihu answer link contains both a question ID and an answer ID. Pass the answer ID to `zhihu.web.fetch_answer_detail` to read the shared answer, or pass the question ID to `zhihu.web.fetch_question_answers` to compare the other answers.** Save both IDs separately, and add the comment ID when you read a discussion.

For example, a colleague shares an answer about daytime home-projector use. Record the answer's conditions before comparing other answers under the same question: room light, screen and model may explain why conclusions differ.

## Which part of the link identifies the object?

The numbers in the table are **format examples**:

| Link shape                          | Identifier to preserve               | Task                                                       |
| ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------------------------- |
| `zhihu.com/question/123`            | `question_id: "123"`                 | Question details and its answers                           |
| `zhihu.com/question/123/answer/456` | Question123 and answer456 separately | One answer, or other answers under question123             |
| `zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/789`          | `article_id: "789"`                  | Column-article details                                     |
| `zhihu.com/people/<token>`          | Profile `url_token`                  | User information/content using the action's declared input |

Keep identifiers as original strings. When a full link already shows the IDs, take them from the path; no extra search is needed. A column article and an answer are different objects, even when both discuss the same subject, so archive them separately.

## Read the shared answer first

Pass the `answer_id` to `zhihu.web.fetch_answer_detail`:

```json
{
  "action": "zhihu.web.fetch_answer_detail",
  "params": {"answer_id": "<confirmed_answer_id>"}
}
```

Send the JSON to `POST https://api.beatapi.io/v1/social-data/call` with normal BeatAPI Bearer authentication. Reuse complete saved material first. In the returned answer, check the author and the parent question, and save the source and the collection time.

## Compare other responses to the question

Pass the question ID to `zhihu.web.fetch_question_answers`:

```json
{
  "action": "zhihu.web.fetch_question_answers",
  "params": {"question_id": "<confirmed_question_id>", "limit": 5, "offset": 0, "order": "default", "cursor": "", "session_id": ""}
}
```

Read a first batch, select the answers relevant to daytime conditions, and fetch individual details only where needed. Record each conclusion with its context; a vote count does not show that everyone agrees. See the [question-research guide](/guides/zhihu-question-archive).

For the example link above, record “question 123 › answer 456.” When you open the answer list for question 123, record a separate answer ID for each answer you add. If you only have a short link, open the short link to get the full URL, then take the IDs from the full path.

## Which object identifies comments and replies?

Answer comments take the `answer_id` in `zhihu.web.fetch_comment_v5`; replies take the `comment_id` in `zhihu.web.fetch_sub_comment_v5`. For example, to add context to a comment that corrects a model, request the replies of that comment; do not pass the question ID as the comment target.

In the comment actions, `order_by` is `score` for popular or `ts` for newest. The answer list uses its own `order` values, `default` and `updated`. Record a question's answer count, an answer's comment count and the number of items you actually read as three separate figures.

## What is the user-identifier exception?

A profile `url_token` is not a numeric ID that every action accepts. In particular, `zhihu.web.fetch_user_segments` names its input `user_url_token` but requires the **member hash id**. Before calling `zhihu.web.fetch_user_segments`, confirm the member hash id; do not reuse a profile token because the field names look alike.

Prompt for the assistant:

> Read this projector answer, keeping question ID, answer ID, author and original source. Review an initial batch of other answers and compare their environments and conditions. Preserve parent context for comment corrections and attach specific sources to conclusions.

Budget the selected answer pages, details and comments with current [pricing](https://beatapi.io/pricing).

[Answer lists versus search](/faq/zhihu-answer-pagination) · [Question-answer research](/guides/zhihu-question-archive)